MERAWI, Ethiopia -- A barefoot farmer named Takele
Tarekegn emerged from his cornfields one day this summer and encountered
engineers and bankers stumbling through the dense bush in front of his
mud-brick shack.
The interlopers, wielding compasses and blueprints, were
blazing a trail to the nearby Koga River. They were also charting what
could be a historic turn in the turbulent water politics of the Nile
River, which have kept millions of Ethiopians on the ragged edge of
starvation.
A small dam is to be built on the Koga, Mr. Tarekegn's
visitors told him, and a network of canals, too -- the first irrigation
project for peasant farmers ever constructed in the area. "If we can
finally use our water, we'll be able to feed our families all year
long," says the 46-year-old farmer. "I have been waiting for
this all my life."
For now, he watches water that could be his salvation
rush away to another man's fields in another country.
Just a half-hour walk from Mr. Tarekegn's parched two
acres of corn and wheat, which are dying of thirst after the rains stopped
too early this year, the Koga picks up speed. It is one of the source
rivers of the mighty Blue Nile, which tumbles through deep gorges as it
carves a 560-mile arc through Ethiopia before entering Sudan. There, the
Blue Nile merges with the White Nile to form the Nile, which surges into
Egypt.
In all, rivers originating in Ethiopia's highlands
contribute 85% of the Nile water flowing through Egypt -- where a vast web
of dams and canals first commissioned by the Pharaohs turn millions of
desert acres into fertile fields. But in Ethiopia, regularly stalked by
drought and famine, precious few drops of the Blue Nile and its
tributaries are dammed to irrigate crops.
Modern geopolitics have favored Egypt because of its
strategic position in the Middle East. Major international lenders and
development agencies have been loath to support anything upstream on the
Nile that might disrupt the vital flow of water to Egypt and trigger
instability there. Ethiopia, meanwhile, lacked funds to develop its own
broad irrigation network. The result is one of Africa's cruelest ironies:
the land that feeds the Nile is unable to feed itself.
Now the hunger in Ethiopia has become so chronic and
widespread that the politics of the Nile are starting to flow in
Ethiopia's direction. International lenders and donors fear that the
number of hungry Ethiopians is increasing beyond the world's ability to
feed them. In the past year, about 13 million Ethiopians have been saved
by 1.7 million tons of food aid, with more than $500 million of food
coming from the U.S. alone. Urgent meetings among major donors this summer
charted a shift away from reliance on emergency aid in favor of long-term
investments, including irrigation and watershed management.
"There is no precedent for a country developing
without harnessing its rivers and utilizing its water resources,"
says David Grey, the World Bank's senior water adviser.
The Nile basin, home to about 160 million people in 10
African countries, has some of the world's worst poverty, hunger and land
degradation. With its population expected to nearly double in 25 years,
the scramble for water will be more intense. The area has long been one of
the most contentious in Africa, convulsing with a series of wars and acts
of terrorism.
Globally, hunger is on the rise. Tuesday, a report by
the United Nations food agency said hunger around the world is increasing,
after falling steadily during the first half of the 1990s. More than 840
million people are undernourished, most of them in Africa and Asia, the
report said, and the number of undernourished people in the developing
world is climbing at a rate of almost 5 million a year.
FPRIVATE "TYPE=PICT;ALT=[Map of Blue Nile
Region]"
Ethiopia, an ancient land of 67 million people, has been
particularly miserable. A war with Eritrea that ended in 2000 sapped money
needed for economic development, leaving the country with an estimated per
capita annual income of about $100, one of the lowest in the world. Life
expectancy is 42 years, and nearly half the children under five are
malnourished.
Since the epic famine of 1984, when nearly one million
people died, Ethiopia has been hit by a series of droughts and food
shortages with each one threatening more people. Families forced to sell
off their cattle and other possessions to survive one drought are too weak
to cope when the next one strikes. With the population growing more than
2% a year, the pressure to squeeze every bit of life out of the land has
depleted the soil and left parts of the country looking like a barren
moonscape. Even in a good harvest year, about five million Ethiopians
still need to be fed by food aid, according to international aid agencies
working in the country.
A more equitable sharing of the Nile, many believe, will
help relieve such misery and tension in the region. The World Bank and the
U.N. are spearheading the Nile Basin Initiative, started in the late 1990s
to foster cooperation among the Nile countries. But the effort faces many
obstacles, including centuries-old suspicions among those who depend on
the Nile.
"This river has caused a hostile environment since
the creation of humans," says Belay Ejigu, Ethiopia's agriculture
minister.
Egypt has historically opposed efforts that could impede
the flow of the Nile to its borders. But now Cairo sees the results of
that stance may be working against Egypt, as an ever-more desperate
Ethiopia has increased pressure to use the Blue Nile basin waters. Rather
than just watch that happen, Egypt wants to have a hand in those projects,
even offering to provide expertise and investment. Egyptians see some
potential economic upside, including the possibility of joint
hydroelectric ventures.
The Koga River project is being cast as a
"confidence builder" to show that upstream uses don't
necessarily hurt downstream populations. Ethiopian engineers calculate the
Koga irrigation would use less than one-tenth of 1% of the Nile flow
reaching the Ethiopia-Sudan border.
Under the plan, some 15,000 acres will be irrigated,
providing supplemental water for crops during the erratic rainy season and
a steady supply of water for a previously unthinkable second crop during
the long dry season. This year, for instance, with the annual rain
starting late and stopping early, Mr. Tarekegn fears his harvest will
shrink by half. "It's the difference between eating well or just
getting by," he says. "Or worse."
When the African Development Bank notified the Egyptians
it was considering financing the $50 million Koga project, Cairo gave its
support. "They are really suffering in Ethiopia," says Abdel
Fattah Metawie, the chairman of the Nile water sector in Egypt's Ministry
of Water Resources and Irrigation. Without development in the Blue Nile
basin, he says, "you have to expect a crisis in the area."
For more than 4,000 miles, the Nile snakes through
jungles, slashes through gorges and floats through deserts, offering some
of the most graceful sights in Africa. Its waters have been deified as a
God and bottled as a holy spirit.
But they have also been defiled by centuries of
jealousy, covetousness and fear. From the time the Pharaohs built the
pyramids along the Nile and first harnessed the river for irrigation,
Egyptians have looked upon the Nile waters as their own. In the colonial
era, European rulers engineered treaties that divvied up use of the lower
Nile between Egypt and Sudan, to the exclusion of Ethiopia, which was
never fully colonized.
During the Cold War, the Soviet Union helped Egypt build
the vast Aswan High Dam to better manage the flow of the Nile. After Egypt
shifted to the Western camp, it was showered with hundreds of millions of
dollars from the U.S. and other allied countries to rehabilitate and
manage its canal network. Ethiopia, which shifted its alliance from West
to East, got mainly military equipment and food aid.
The disparity of fortunes is stark. Egypt has eight
million acres of land irrigated by thousands of miles of Nile canals,
while Ethiopia has less than 500,000 acres of irrigated land. Although
Ethiopia's highlands boast vast stretches of arable land, they must rely
on the erratic rains for, at best, one crop each year. Because of its
irrigation supply, Egyptian farmers can annually produce two or three
harvest seasons.
Egypt exports power. Ethiopia produces less than 500
megawatts from a few hydropower dams, providing electricity to less than
10% of the population. Ethiopia's Ministry of Water Resources estimates
its rivers, chiefly the Blue Nile, have the potential to produce more than
15,000 megawatts of power and irrigate nearly nine million acres -- if it
gets the cooperation and investment.
"The international community has to understand
this, rather than just give us food handouts," says Shiferaw Jarso,
Ethiopia's minister of water resources. "This year, the U.S. gives us
$500 million in food aid and it's gone within one year. People get the
food, but it never brings additional value for the country. If this money
goes to a power project or irrigation, it can keep on helping every
year."
According to the region's new math, what helps Ethiopia
can also help Egypt. The countries are studying a plan for four hydropower
dams on the Blue Nile. These dams could produce enough energy not only to
supply Ethiopia's domestic demand but also to feed into Egypt's extensive
power grid for sale to users all the way up to Europe.
The dams would also serve as sediment traps for the
topsoil that washes down from Ethiopia's denuded hillsides. Currently, the
silt from the Blue Nile is building up in Egypt's Aswan Dam and a couple
of smaller dams in Sudan. Over time, if the runoff isn't controlled, the
silting could cripple the dams.
Engineers from both countries agree that dams in the
cool and moist Ethiopian highlands, storing water in deep natural gorges,
would lose far less water to evaporation than the Aswan Dam in the hot,
dry Egyptian desert. They calculate the savings on evaporation could
compensate for the amount of water Ethiopia proposes to use for
irrigation.
"There's enough water -- it is a matter of managing
it," says Egypt's Mr. Metawie. "To look at the Nile from a
selfish point of view won't help anyone."
Still, plenty of people remain wary, particularly
Egyptian farmers. Despite the calculations of their experts, many farmers,
such as Samir Hamed, fear that any use of Nile water upstream would mean
that less is available to them.
Mr. Hamed, 45, tends about 200 acres on the far edge of
the Nile Delta. His is the last farm before the desert. But thanks to the
network of canals and pumping stations, his land is alive with apples,
grapes, apricots, cucumbers, pepper, broccoli, Brussels sprouts, cherry
tomatoes and eggplant, plus 600 head of cattle. Through a U.S.-sponsored
program called AgLink, he has refined his farm management, even learning
how to use a shower system to cool off his water buffalo calves. That,
too, is Nile water.
What if Ethiopian farmers would tap the Nile like he
does? "I'm sure it would effect the amount of water we can use,"
Mr. Hamed says. "Without the Nile water, I can't plant or raise
cattle."
That is something too ghastly for Mohamed Abd-Elsalam,
another Egyptian farmer, to contemplate. "The Nile is my soul. And
without a soul a man is dead," he says. A narrow V-shaped concrete
canal delivers the Nile waters to his one-acre plot, where wheat, garlic,
seed oil and alfalfa grow year-round. If anything slows the flow of the
river to his land, he says, "I'll go to Ethiopia and farm. I'll
follow the water."
Overcoming these life-and-death concerns is a major part
of the Nile Basin Initiative. In the past two years, the Ethiopians have
given Blue Nile tours to Egyptians who shape public opinion on water use
-- officials in the Ministry of Water Resources and Irrigation,
parliamentarians and journalists. Some of them have been the harshest
critics of Ethiopia's motives, accusing Ethiopia of clandestine
dam-building projects supported by Israel and the U.S. to block the Nile
waters and starve Egypt.
The tours have included helicopter rides over the Blue
Nile basin to prove that such dam projects don't exist. The Egyptians also
visited some of the most impoverished and hungry regions of the country,
and those that are the most denuded, where rivulets thick with soil run
down the hills into the Blue Nile and eventually into Egypt.
"The Egyptians were really surprised. There weren't
even any trees," says Yacob Wondimkun, the commissioner for
sustainable agriculture and environmental rehabilitation in Ethiopia's
Amhara region. The conclusion, he says, was clear: "Unless we have
watershed management in Ethiopia, the whole system will be hurt."
Abbas Al Tarabeely, editor of the Egyptian newspaper Al
Wafd, took his suspicions on one of the trips. He returned to Cairo with
ideas. "Why not create water-storage areas for irrigation, like small
dams? They would help relieve suffering while also not placing too much
burden on the Nile," he says. "It is important to let Egyptians
know that the Ethiopians are going through enough without making matters
worse by focusing on conspiracy theories."
That may ease the frustration of people such as Tesfahun
Belachew, an Ethiopian farmer, whose land is near the Ribb River, another
of the Blue Nile's tributaries. For the past nine months, as the mercurial
weather has ruined his crops, his family has survived on food aid from
abroad. His one-acre field floods when the rains are good and the river
rampages. When the rains fail, his crops wither while the river meanders
by. There are no dams to regulate the flow, no canals or pumps to drain
the fields during flooding or release the water during drought.
"The water is right here," he says, "but
we can't get it out."
Source: Ocnus.net 2004
|